Nada Surf


(Copyright © 1999 Piero Scaruffi | Legal restrictions - Termini d'uso )
High/Low , 5/10
Proximity Effect (1998) , 4/10
Let Go (2002) , 6.5/10
The Weight Is A Gift (2005), 6/10
Lucky (2008), 6/10
Links:

Beniamini di Ric Ocasek, i Nada Surf suonano il piu` classico "guitar rock", quello che di questi tempi non potrebbe essere piu` anacronistico. Per loro fortuna Matthew Caws e` un cantante-chitarrista di pathos e passione, e la sezione ritmica di Daniel Lorca e Ira Elliot e` di tutto rispetto. Peccato che su High/Low (Elektra, 1996) (a parte Deeper Well) manchi la verve, e peccato che (a parte l'hit Popular e Psychic Caramel) manchino le melodie. Nel grande zoo di New York fanno la figura delle educande. If English is your first language and you could translate the Italian text, please contact me.
Proximity Effect (MarDev, 1998 - Elektra, 2000) has little to commend itself. Hyperspace tries to emulate their 1996 hit, but it is the dreamy ballad 80 Windows that steals the show. The rest is as uninspired as rock can be.

The band literally reinvented themselves on Let Go (Labels, 2002 - Barsuk, 2003), their most inspired album yet, overflowing with gently melodic gems while exuding anger and frustration. Somehow, their melodic skills were emphasized by a humbler, more sincere context, and the variety of formats stretched from ballad to rock'n'roll in a way that they had never dreamed of before. With gentle ballads such as Blizzard of '77, Inside of Love and Neither Heaven Nor Space they de facto pioneered a sort of "Seventies revival", a sound that harked back to the mellowest moments of the Alan Parsons Project and the Electric Light Orchestra. At the same time they continued to revise Tom Petty's slick driving folk-rock (Happy Kid, Treading Water) that, with a bit more of emphasis and rhythm, allowed them to coin a poppy version of the Velvet Underground (The Way You Wear Your Head, the album's standout). While the album had no ambition to reinvent rock music, the skipping beats and hard riffs of Hi-Speed Soul and the seven-minute mutation of Paper Boats from catatonic to soaring showed craftmanship above the average.

The Weight Is A Gift (Barsuk, 2005 - Sonic Boom, 2006) was louder and faster but, generally speaking, continued the orgy of self-analysis and of flamboyant melodic revival. This time the band's preference went clearly towards the bittersweet ballad, but the way they packaged it was so tasty and poignant that the parade was never monotonous: the comatose Comes A Time, Do It Again, What Is Your Secret, employ an arsenal of little tricks to keep Matthew Caws' lyrics alive and kicking. The vocal and instrumental arrangements of Your Legs Grow even border on dream-pop. Furthermore, the stereotype of the pop ballad is violated by the frenzied tempo of Concrete Bed, the burning guitar of Always Love, the collective pounding of In The Mirror, the punkish energy of Imaginary Friends, and especially by the infectious beat of Blankest Year.

The songs on Lucky (Barsuk, 2008) were less immediate than the ones The Weight Is A Gift, but the procedure was very similar. Whose Authority, Beautiful Beat, See These Bones and I Like What You Say displayed the same confidence in building and sustaining pop magic, while Weightless and The Fox veered towards brooding atmospheres. None (except maybe Ice On The Wing) has the verve of the best Sixties revival.

(Translation by/ Tradotto da Massimo Mascia)

In Proximity Effect (MarDev, 1998 - Elektra, 2000) c'è poco di cui vantarsi. Hyperspace tenta di bissare il loro hit del '96, ma a rubare la scena è la ballata trasognata 80 Windows. Il resto è tanto povero di idee quanto sa esserlo il rock.

La band si reinventò letteralmente con Let Go (Labels, 2002 - Barsuk, 2003), ad oggi il loro album più ispirato, traboccante di delicate gemme melodiche come Blizzard of '77 e Treading Water, ma anche trasudante una vena di rabbia e frustrazione. In qualche modo, le loro abilità melodiche risultano enfatizzate dal contesto più modesto e sincero, e la varietà dei formati canzone spazia dalla ballata al rock'n'roll in una maniera che non si erano mai sognati.

The Weight Is A Gift (Barsuk, 2005 - Sonic Boom, 2006) è più leggero e un pizzico troppo indulgente, ma in linea di massima porta avanti l'orgia di auto-analisi e di revival melodico flamboyant. Questa volta le preferenze della band vanno chiaramente in direzione della ballata agrodolce, ma il modo in cui la infiocchettano è talmente creativo e toccante che la sfilata di canzoni non è mai monotona: Comes in Time, Do It Again, What Is Your Secret e Always Love sfoderano un arsenale di trucchi da repertorio per mantenere i testi di Matthew Caws freschi e vitali.

Le canzoni di Lucky (Barsuk, 2008) sono meno immediate rispetto a The Weight Is A Gift, ma la procedura compositiva è assai simile. Whose Authority, Beautiful Beat, See These Bones and I Like What You Say rivelano la medesima sicurezza nella costruzione e nel sostenimento della magia pop, mentre Weightless e The Fox sterzano verso atmosfere introspettive. Ma nessuna, eccezion fatta forse per Ice On The Wing, ha la verve del miglior revival anni '60.

What is unique about this music database